top of page
Writer's pictureHazel Murphy

DIY vs. Hiring a Handyman: A Guide for Homeowners in Lafayette, Indiana

DIY or Hire a Handyman? Making the Right Choice for Your Home Repairs

When it comes to home repairs and improvement projects, deciding whether to tackle the job yourself or hire a professional can be challenging. At Greater Lafayette Handy Services, we understand the importance of making informed decisions that save you time, money, and stress. This guide will help you determine when it's worth doing a job yourself and when it's better to reach out to a handyman service like ours.


Considerations for DIY vs. Hiring a Handyman


  1. Skill and Experience

  • DIY: If you have experience and the necessary skills for the task, DIY can be a viable option.

  • Hire a Handyman: For complex tasks that require specific expertise or tools, hiring a professional ensures the job is done correctly and safely.

  1. Time Investment

  • DIY: Consider how much time the project will take. If you have limited free time, a DIY project might drag on longer than anticipated.

  • Hire a Handyman: A professional can complete the job more efficiently, allowing you to focus on other priorities.

  1. Cost of Materials and Tools

  • DIY: Factor in the cost of purchasing or renting tools and materials. For one-time projects, these costs can add up quickly.

  • Hire a Handyman: Professionals come equipped with the necessary tools, saving you the expense of buying or renting them.

  1. Quality and Safety

  • DIY: Consider whether you can achieve the desired quality and safety standards. Mistakes can lead to additional costs and potential hazards.

  • Hire a Handyman: Professionals ensure high-quality work and adherence to safety standards, reducing the risk of future problems.


Cost Comparison: DIY vs. Hiring a Handyman


Let’s break down the costs using a simple example: replacing a faucet.

  • DIY Costs:

  • Faucet: $100

  • Tools (wrench, plumber’s tape, etc.): $50

  • Time: 4 hours (If you value your time at $25/hour, that’s $100)

  • Total DIY Cost: $250

  • Hiring a Handyman:

  • Labor (at $75/hour for 2 hours): $150

  • Faucet: $100

  • Total Handyman Cost: $250

In this example, the costs are similar, but hiring a handyman saves you 4 hours of your time and ensures the job is done correctly and safely.


Situations Where Hiring a Professional Always Makes Sense


  1. Electrical Work: Safety is paramount with electrical projects. Mistakes can be dangerous and costly.

  2. Plumbing Repairs: Improper repairs can lead to water damage and higher future repair costs.

  3. Structural Changes: Projects involving structural changes to your home require professional expertise to ensure safety and compliance with building codes.

  4. Complex Carpentry: Custom builds or intricate woodwork are best handled by experienced carpenters.

  5. Large-Scale Painting Projects: Professional painters can complete the job faster and with a higher-quality finish.


Decision-Making Flow Chart

I created this flow chart as a quick reference that should help if you're unsure whether to call a professional or to tackle a job yourself:


Flow chart for deciding if you should hire a handyman or tackle the job yourself
Flow chart for deciding if you should hire a handyman or tackle the job yourself


Conclusion

When deciding between DIY vs hiring a handyman, consider your skills, time, and the complexity of the task. For many projects, especially those involving safety or specialized knowledge, hiring a professional handyman service like Greater Lafayette Handy Services can save you time, money, and stress. Contact us today to discuss your home repair and improvement needs and let us help you get the job done right!


4 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page